Politics & Law

Correctional madness: Realignment on the right track in L.A.

Jonathan Simon

“The California Report” and the Center for Investigative Reporting posted another excellent report on realignment this morning (broadcast on many NPR stations and available online after a delay here — this one focused on the vital issue of how counties, which get both resources and discretion over post-prison supervision for many California prisoners, are working with former prisoners who live with mental illness.  This is crucial.  As the Supreme Court highlighted in Brown v. Plata, California’s overcrowded reception-center prisons were machines of madness, taking parolees already suffering from lack of adequate treatment in the community, and typically throwing them back in prison in response to their deteriorating behavior.  Once in prison, an inadequate mental healthcare system, paralyzed by near 300% capacity population at many reception centers, has led these prisoners to deteriorate further, in time to be released on parole again in even worse shape.

Los Angeles County, which has been struggling with the criminalization of mental illness since the 1970s, appears from the report to be taking a very strong approach, with an emphasis on wrap-around services, housing (because many of parolees with mental illness end up on the street), and a clear intent to avoid unnecessary incarcerations in response to minor violations.  Much of the program is being operated by an NGO specializing in delivering services to people with mental illness, rather than a law-enforcement agency focused on punishment and control and deeply hostile to the idea of mental illness after decades of official anti-medicine in California.  Paradoxically this approach seems to actually produce valuable intelligence about real crime and the ability to distinguish between truly emerging threats and simple setbacks or relapses (say, on drug use) — just the kind of intelligence that contemporary corrections and law enforcement has largely lost the capacity to produce over the past 40 years.

This was highlighted in the episode by an interview with an LAPD officer assigned to a special re-entry unit.  While one might hope that such a unit would benefit from the kind of individualized thinking emerging from the NGO side of the re-entry enterprise, it was not apparent from the interview.  Instead, the officer suggested that many parolees might be hiding out in mental hospitals to avoid arrest for serious crimes.  This suggests a basic lack of awareness of mental health hospitalization opportunities in California (it is quite hard even for people with florid symptoms to get hospitalized) as well as a skepticism about the reality of mental illness that unfortunately is pervasive in law enforcement.

As good as the realignment approach in LA with regard to former prisoners with mental illnesses sounds, it begs another question.  Why are we letting so many people with mental illness drift into our criminal-justice system as our primary way of getting them needed treatment?

Cross-posted from Jonathan Simon’s blog Governing Through Crime.

Bookmark and Share
Comments to "Correctional madness: Realignment on the right track in L.A.":
    • Bpratt1424

      Professor: Any correlation between the implementation of realignment in October and the huge spike in property and violent crimes during the 1st 6 months of 2012 in cities throughout CA? Just curious…..

      San Jose homicide tally hits 31, on pace to beat 15-year high

      By Robert Salonga

      rsalonga@mercurynews.com

      Posted: 08/21/2012 05:36:10 PM PDT

      Click photo to enlarge

      A San Jose Police Department investigator inspects a car containing the body of a… ( Gary Reyes )
      Homicide maps
      Map: San Jose homicides in 2012, with link to previous years’ maps.
      San Jose police Chief Chris Moore briefed a city commission last week on a crime surge in the first six months of 2012, highlighted by double-digit spikes in burglaries, robberies, rapes, stolen cars and other thefts over last year.

      He offered a small silver lining: Homicides were down 9 percent.

      Eight days changed all that. San Jose has seen one of the bloodiest stretches in its history, with seven people killed and five other people shot and wounded from Aug. 13 through Tuesday evening.

      [Report abuse]

Leave a comment

 

 

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>


9 + = 12