Skip to main content

Botched execution

Jonathan Simon, professor of law | May 1, 2014

To “botch” something is to carry out a task “badly or carelessly.”  Oklahoma’s botched execution Tuesday, April 29, 2014 demonstrated that word in its absolute in-glory.  (Read the New York Times account here).

Badly? Executions always cause at least psychological pain.  Even if everything goes perfectly, the physical pains involved in injecting the drugs may not be trivial either, especially when stripped of its normal healing association and replaced by the grimmest.

Still, an execution can be carried out badly in countless ways when it causes additional anxiety, humiliation, and physical pain.  The execution of Clayton Lockett as witnessed by reporters was badly done in just this sense.  Prison officials said Lockett’s vein “exploded.”  Lockett was seen to writhe and shake uncontrollably, attempted to rise up from the gurney to which he had minutes earlier been completely strapped down, and cried out “man”; all after execution officials had announced him unconscious.

Gov. Mary Fallin

Oklahoma Gov. Mary Fallin

Officials apparently blamed the condition of Lockett’s veins and further investigation is promised, but these events are extreme for executions in the modern era and fully profile the case that defense lawyers have been making for years that lethal injections in some cases can amount to torture.

But where Oklahoma Governor Mary Fallin and the state’s legislators wrote the book on botched is on the “carelessly” branch of the term.  In their zeal to assure a supply of lethal chemicals to kill prisoners at a time when supplies have become scarce due to international revulsion at American capital punishment, Oklahoma politicians passed a law shielding the sources of the execution drugs and adamantly refused defense requests for information about their origins.

When the Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals (the state’s highest court for criminal appeals) refused to stay the execution despite a lower court having found that Lockett had a right to information about the drugs,  the Oklahoma Supreme Court, which has no regular jurisdiction over criminal appeals, stepped in to issue a highly unusual stay in the interests of justice, only to retreat after the Governor and legislature furiously attacked the jurists, threatening to ignore their decision and impeach them as well.

Not content with having bullied the courts out of the way, and eager to show how trivial defense concerns about the execution drugs were,  Governor Fallin ordered a double execution, a rarity in the modern era and the first in Oklahoma since 1937.

Executions, even when they are not botched, exact a horrible toll on remaining prisoners (both those on death row and in the general population) and on prison staff.  A double execution is a heinous act of cruelty on the entire prison system which  was motivated by the unseemly rush to see executions carried out before courts could fully examine the defense arguments that these lethal chemicals might cause extreme pain to Clayton Lockett and other condemned prisoners.

Careless is not just bad; in a real sense, it’s evil.  You can do something badly for a lot of reasons (often conflicting interests or roles), but to do it carelessly is to do it without care.  When we say that carpenter was “careless” in building a stair case that collapsed, or a designer was careless in designing an automobile that crashed, what we really mean is that they did their task without caring about the humanity of those who would walk on the stairs or drive the car.

Governor Mary Fallin and Oklahoma officials rushed an execution without caring about the humanity of Clayton Lockett and Charles Warner.  In doing so they raised serious questions as to whether Oklahoma’s death penalty inherently violates the Eighth Amendment, which has been recently found to be animated by respect for human dignity.

…And then they botched the execution.

In his just-published (and incredibly timely) book Gruesome Spectacles: Botched Executions and America’s Death Penalty (Stanford 2014), Austin Sarat shows that Oklahoma’s botched execution may be textbook but it’s not unique.  Botched executions are persistent theme in America’s capital punishment history, largely fueled by our national combination of uncertain respect for human dignity, and misplaced technological optimism.

By the way, the intensity of Oklahoma’s leaders in their pursuit of retributive justice should be put in context of their general lack of interest in governing. The state ranks 44th in overall poverty, 43 in infant mortality, 47 for cancer mortality.

Cross-posted from Jonathan Simon’s blog Governing Through Crime.

Comments to “Botched execution

  1. Google “Benejuzar” and “rapist” and then you will know what a proper execution looks like.

  2. “an execution can be carried out badly in countless ways when it causes additional anxiety, humiliation, and physical pain.”

    Huh? That sounds like a great execution for this scumbag.

    “Careless is not just bad; in a real sense, it’s evil.”

    Yes, if by “evil” Simon means good

  3. Botched execution or KARMA?

    “Death row inmate killed teen because she wouldn’t back down”

    ….Lockett later told police “he decided to kill Stephanie because she would not agree to keep quiet,” court records state.

    Neiman was forced to watch as Lockett’s accomplice, Shawn Mathis, spent 20 minutes digging a shallow grave in a ditch beside the road. Her friends saw Neiman standing in the ditch and heard a single shot.

    Lockett returned to the truck because the gun had jammed. He later said he could hear Neiman pleading, “Oh God, please, please” as he fixed the shotgun.

    The men could be heard “laughing about how tough Stephanie was” before Lockett shot Neiman a second time.

    “He ordered Mathis to bury her, despite the fact that Mathis informed him Stephanie was still alive.”

    Bornt and Neiman’s friend “were threatened that if they told anybody about these events, they too would be murdered,” court records state.

    “Every day we are left with horrific images of what the last hours of Stephanie’s life was like,” her parents’ impact statement says.

    See Tulsa World article here.

Comments are closed.